Latest news about Bitcoin and all cryptocurrencies. Your daily crypto news habit.
Iâve been thinking lately about the cult of My-idea-ism.
What is My-idea-ism?
My-idea-ism is the need for your idea to âwinâ. It is the antithesis of Our-idea-ism, or perhaps more importantly Right-idea-ismâŠwhere a team progressively explores options to solve a compelling (and valuable) problem, and settles on the best path forward based on evidence.
My-idea-ism permeates modern organizations, especially here in the United States, where we are highly individualistic, assertive, and competitive, and have lower long-term orientation (source). Reflect on how promotions often hinge on âpushing your idea through to completionâ vs. whether it was necessarily the right idea, or whether you empowered others to dream up even better ideas. We value decisiveness, âvisionâ, having the answers, and filling the backlog, and devalue ambiguity, and risking âanalysis paralysisâ.
Meeting adjourned! Pitch made! Letâs go! Ship it!
Almost every product manager has gotten this call late on a Friday afternoon âŠ
We have a board meeting coming up, and it is super important that we bring up some of the cool stuff we have planned! What do we have planned? What will pique their interest? If it gets green lighted ⊠youâll get to own it! Update the deck, OK?
Youâre rewarded for the rapid reply (the My-idea-ism) in this case. You dream up a persuasive story, something that âpopsâ and seems coherent, and you replyâŠeven if you have reservations. My-idea-ism funds your team. My-idea-ism gets you headcount. My-idea-ism gives a great fodder for your resume. Itâs compelling. Nothing is more comforting than a neat and tidy feature-laden roadmap :)
The battle of (and for) ideas can be fierce. Some organizations openly pit PMs against each other to get their âprojectâ or âproductâ (note, their ideas, or at least unique views of the problem) âgreen-lightedâ. Sure ⊠in an ideal world they would pitch the value of solving a particular problem, but it tends to not stop there. Drop some shiny objectsââ some machine learning, perhapsââ and youâre good to go. This could explain why MBAs with consulting experience (with all that experience making ârecommendationsâ and pitching) tend to advance in certain environments.
So is My-idea-ism just a part of how companies work? For the many brilliant people I know who arenât natural âpitchersâ and presenters, and who choose to step back and ponder the actual problem, I sure hope not. Same goes for improving the quality of our decisions, quality of our products, and well-being of our teams.
I remember talking to a newly hired, and highly skilled software architect from Europe (from a more âcollectiveâ work culture). They were blown away by the competition for tech stack choices, and the âright to ownâ the projectâŠvs accepting that no solution would be perfect, and to start collaboratively validating key assumptions. It was a major shift, and not a path he was willing to take.
On a similar note, Iâll never forget a software developer tentatively dropping an amazing idea on the teamâŠweeks after the more vocal team members had converged. After some private conversations, I learned that they simply couldnât get a word in edge-wise. The problem had persisted for years.
My biased opinion is that My-idea-ism eventually bites you. At least based on what Iâve seen. It can help your career, depending on where you work. But in the long run (and yes, weâre not as long-term oriented here in the States), becoming awesome at bringing context, and data to teams, and inspiring the best collective solutions will win the day. Youâll become a force-multiplier.
As a next step: When presenting, imagine that youâre framing the problem so that it is completely solution agnostic. What data/context could you give the whole team, such that anyone could pitch their idea. Focus on that context. Focus on valuable problems to solve. Focus on a framework for decision making. You might have a âgreat ideaâ, but offer it as one option, and make sure it fits your framework.
Make the move to Right-idea-ism.
My-idea-ism was originally published in Hacker Noon on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.
Disclaimer
The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not reflect the views of Bitcoin Insider. Every investment and trading move involves risk - this is especially true for cryptocurrencies given their volatility. We strongly advise our readers to conduct their own research when making a decision.